Why Wicked Problems Defy Quick Fixes in Business and Beyond
🔟 Ten Properties of Wicked Problems
Horst Rittel, along with Melvin Webber, outlined the concept of wicked problems in a 1973 paper (Read the paper Here) to describe complex social planning issues that defy simple solutions. These problems are “wicked” not because they’re evil, but because they are resistant to resolution. Rittel listed ten key properties of wicked problems. Here’s an explanation of each one.
🧩 1. No Definitive Formulation
“The information needed to understand the problem depends upon one’s idea for solving it.”
Explanation: You can’t write a final, complete definition of a wicked problem. Understanding it is intertwined with how you might try to solve it. Each stakeholder may define the problem differently.
🔁 2. No Stopping Rule
“You can’t say ‘This is the final solution.’”
Explanation: Unlike math problems, there’s no point where you’re done. You can always try to improve the solution, and any solution is somewhat provisional.
🧪 3. Solutions Are Not True-or-False, but Good-or-Bad
“Evaluation is subjective and depends on values, not just data.”
Explanation: You can’t test a wicked problem solution like a scientific hypothesis. People judge them as better or worse based on their perspectives.
🦋 4. No Immediate or Ultimate Test of a Solution
“The effects unfold over time, often with unintended consequences.”
Explanation: You might implement a solution and only years later realize it made things worse. There’s no lab to test it in advance.
🏗️ 5. One-Shot Operations
“Every attempt counts significantly; no trial runs.”
Explanation: You can’t “undo” a Strategy policy change. Every intervention changes the context and the problem.
🧶 6. No Exhaustive List of Solutions
“There’s no definitive inventory of possible answers.”
Explanation: Unlike chess, where all moves are known, the solution space for wicked problems is open-ended and evolves with the problem itself.
🔄 7. Each Problem Is Essentially Unique
“No two wicked problems are the same.”
Explanation: Though they might appear similar, context matters. Solutions that work in one organization or era may fail in another due to cultural, political, or technological differences.
🔄 8. Each Problem Can Be a Symptom of Another
“Wicked problems are often entangled.”
Explanation: Poverty, for example, may be tied to education, which is tied to governance, which is tied to trust. Solving one piece often means addressing others too.
👥 9. Choices Define the Problem
“How you frame the problem determines your solution path.”
Explanation: If you see traffic congestion as a road issue, you widen roads. If you see it as a behavior issue, you improve public transit. Framing shapes action.
⚖️ 10. Planners Have No Right to Be Wrong
“… planners are accountable.”
Explanation: Scientists can publish failed theories and move on, but policy makers face real consequences—economic, political, or human—if their plans fail.
💼 Wicked Problems in a Business Context
Wicked problems are not limited to public planning or policy — they thrive inside businesses, too. Strategic dilemmas like entering new markets, managing cultural change, or transforming IT infrastructure often show all ten characteristics of wickedness. Each stakeholder sees the problem differently. There’s no clear finish line. And every solution changes the landscape.
For example:
- “Why are we losing market share?” — Depends who you ask: Sales blames pricing; Marketing blames product; Product blames leadership.
- “Should we move to the cloud?” — It’s not a technical choice alone; it’s a cultural, financial, and strategic transformation.
The more complex, interconnected, and value-laden the issue, the more likely you’re facing a wicked problem.
📋 Typical Wicked Problems in Business
- SAP HANA: Case Study 1
- System Migrations: Case Study 2
- Offshoring
- Re-shoring
- Digital transformation & cloud migration
- Reinventing the business model
- Post-merger integration
- Creating a data-driven culture
- Diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs
- Workforce engagement in hybrid environments
- Customer experience reinvention
- Sustainability/ESG compliance & reporting
- AI adoption across business functions
- Vendor lock-in versus open architecture strategies
These are not “problems to be solved,” but realities to be navigated over time.
🧠 Implications for Leaders and Managers
Traditional management tools — root cause analysis, Gantt charts, benchmarking — are often inadequate for wicked problems. Instead, leaders need:
- Sensemaking over certainty — Embrace complexity rather than prematurely simplifying it.
- Facilitation over command — Coordinate diverse perspectives instead of imposing a single view.
- Experimentation over execution — Pilot ideas with room to adapt, rather than betting on big-bang implementations.
- Alignment over solutioning — Get stakeholders on the same page before getting to work.
- Learning over planning — Invest in reflection loops and feedback systems rather than fixed plans.
Wicked problems demand leadership styles that are adaptive, humble, and iterative.
🛠️ How to Approach (Not “Solve”) a Wicked Problem
You don’t solve wicked problems — you learn to work with them. Here’s how:
- Recognize the wickedness Use Rittel’s 10 properties as a checklist. If you’re stuck in stakeholder conflict or perpetual redefinition — it’s wicked.
- Engage diverse stakeholders early Involve users, customers, frontline employees, and skeptics. Surface multiple definitions of the problem. Use dialogue mapping or systems thinking workshops to reveal contradictions.
- Frame and reframe the challenge The way you pose the problem shapes your solutions. Keep updating your framing as new insights emerge.
- Prototype and iterate Test responses in small ways. Launch pilots. Treat feedback not as failure but as intelligence.
- Manage trade-offs transparently There are no perfect answers. Be clear about what’s being prioritized, and what’s being let go — and why.
- Use supportive frameworks
- 📉 Force Field Analysis – to weigh drivers vs. barriers
- 🔗 Systems Thinking – to uncover feedback loops
- Make decisions despite uncertainty Use bounded risk, incremental steps, and stakeholder trust to move forward even when outcomes are unknowable.
In wicked contexts, the goal is not perfection — it’s progress, learning, and agility.
🌱 Final Thought: Navigating the Fog, Not Finding the Finish Line
Wicked problems don’t go away with better KPIs or more funding. They persist, evolve, and defy closure. But with the right mindset — one that favors humility over hubris, framing over fixing, and learning over locking-in — they can be navigated thoughtfully and collaboratively.
Leaders who recognize wickedness can avoid costly oversimplification. They ask better questions, engage broader coalitions, and create room for responsible experimentation. They lead with empathy, transparency, and an eye toward the long arc of strategic impact.
This isn’t about solving the unsolvable — it’s about making wiser moves in the midst of uncertainty.
📚 Up Next: Wicked Problems in Action
This post launches a series of real-world case studies exploring how organizations face wicked problems in practice — with varying success:
- Case Study 1: SAP HANA — Innovation vs. legacy inertia
- Case Study 2: System Migrations
Subscribe below to get notified when each story drops — and receive the Wicked Problem Audit Template free as a bonus.
🎯 Get Smarter About Wicked Problems
Subscribe to the Do Different newsletter and get the Wicked Problem Audit Template free — plus insights on strategy, systems thinking, and real-world leadership in complex environments.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. We only send thoughtful strategy content, twice a month.
Resources and Further Reading
More Details on Each Property
Follow the Links
- No definitive formulation of a wicked problem
- No stopping rule
- Solutions are not true-or-false, but better-or-worse
- No immediate and no ultimate test of a solution
- Every solution is a one-shot operation (no trial-and-error learning)
- No enumerable or exhaustively describable set of solutions
- Every wicked problem is essentially unique
- Every wicked problem can be considered a symptom of another problem
- The choice of explanation determines the resolution
- Planners have no right to be wrong